Websense News & Views
all posts insights blog news releases media coverage accolades

Published Tuesday, November 01, 2011 3:52 PM by Michael Newman

There are many stories in the news this week about how US technology is used by repressive regimes to censor internet content, possibly in violation of trade sanctions and embargoes. Given the role of the internet in the recent Arab Spring uprisings, it is little wonder why repressive regimes seek to stifle online education and communication that they see as threatening.

Is it appropriate for American businesses to claim that technology is morally neutral, and therefore absolve themselves of responsibility for its use? 

No. American software companies should take strong measures to prevent the misuse of their technologies where it would be harmful to the public good. And it’s long overdue for American technology companies to step forward and address this problem.

Websense is a world leader in protecting corporate data, and has for years also been the world leader in web filtering, a type of software that allows organizations to choose what web content is permissible for their employees to access in the workplace.  Websense does not support the use of our software for the purposes of government censorship and Websense does not sell to governments for the purposes of censorship.

To illustrate, several years ago a Yemeni internet service provider purchased Websense filtering software from a third party and pirated it to censor Yemeni citizens. When Websense learned of the pirated software being used for censorship, we disabled it, preventing the Yemeni ISP from continuing to misuse and abuse Websense software. This business would have been 100% legal for Websense to pursue; yet we took the moral and ethical stand to cede that business to the competition.  And just last month, we detected—and blocked—two attempts to use our software using cloaked addresses in Europe that were actually fronts for entities in Syria, a country subject to trade sanctions by the United States. This is not rocket science, but it does take some moral fiber, smart people, commitment, and follow-through.

Websense has been highly transparent in our position on censorship and the full text of our anti-censorship policy is publicly available to all of our customers and competitors on our website.  But instead of being a lone voice for this cause, we are issuing a call to action to the industry and stakeholders. We challenge all other American technology vendors to join us in prohibiting repressive regimes from using American technology to prevent open communications. As a U.S. organization, based in a country founded on the right of free speech, we believe that other companies should adopt ethical policies and technical measures that prevent their software and products from being used to restrict the communications freedoms that the internet affords every global citizen.

Technology can be both empowering and repressive. Families and communities grow, prosper, and share information online. Yet, repressive regimes suppress these voices by blocking access to content they perceive as unsettling or threatening. 

If you are a shareholder of a U.S. technology company, write to your leaders. If you are a citizen concerned with this issue, reach out to the companies that make these types of software and ask that they adopt a non-censorship policy similar to Websense. Reach out to organizations like the Open Net Initiative and the Electronic Frontier Foundation to ensure that they get the story right and understand how you can support ongoing, free discourse throughout the globe.

If you are an executive at a security company that makes software that can be used to censor internet activity in repressive regimes, we ask that you support the right course of action and stop selling repressive tools to oppressive regimes.

 

Filed under:

Comments

Peter Burgess said on Nov 07, 2011

Thank you ... I particularly liked the idea that 'moral fiber' was used to address issues that were legal but wrong by any moral and ethical compass. Thank you!


West Papua Media Editor said on Aug 10, 2012

Once again a nice sounding public affairs spiel, but the fact is that websense continues to censor many many sites of human rights and independent media around the world.  

In the last few days, I have routinely been blocked for almost any secure website, and for secure communications - technologies that prevent repressive regimes from spying and killing their citizens.

Further more, lifesaving technologies like Psiphon are routinely blocked as are encrypted email sites and other things that journalists and activists rely on.

People get routinely killed, arrested and tortured because they cannot get past your firewall.

Start telling the truth Websense and be honest.  Otherwise your so called  moral stand is just a complete lie.

Public affairs spin must be back up by active whitelisting at the core of the product, or you are just hypocrites.

And let us see if this gets approved... if you do not then that will be another sign of censorship.


Matthew Mors Websense author said on Aug 10, 2012

Thank you for taking the time to engage us with your comment. If you have evidence of a specific violation of our censorship policy (www.websense.com/.../censorship-policy.aspx) please send us information directly at pr@websense.com and we will investigate immediately.

If we find a violation, we will look to address it immediately, similar to how we dealt with a violation of our anti-censorship policy in Yemen: community.websense.com/.../websense-issues-statement-on-use-of-its-url-filtering-technology-by-isps-in-yemen.aspx.

We understand that you may be skeptical of our intent in taking a public stand in this manner. Many companies do put out hollow statements that aren’t backed up by action. We however, are different, and we hold to this policy as a core of our businesses practices. But, you don’t have to take our word for it.

For third party validation of our efforts, please feel free to reach out to the Electronic Frontier Foundation, www.eff.org/.../filtering-software-companies-should-follow-websenses-lead, The Global Network Initiative: www.globalnetworkinitiative.org or the Open Net Initiative. These groups specifically watch for government use of censorship tools, and all can report on their independent research on the current state of use of Websense technology among governments.


Leave a comment

Note: comments are moderated and are not confidential emails to the blogger

(required) 

Email address: (required)